Back to the journal

Behaviour as communication when there is no class

What the SEND code of practice and DfE guidance say about the unmet need behind difficult behaviour, for an adult teaching one child at a time.

About this articleJames taught for twelve years in a special school and is Deputy Designated Safeguarding Lead.

Choose how to view this article
Transcript

In a school, behaviour is managed with a policy. A tutor working with one child has none of that. The three documents that cover behaviour each ask the adult to consider what lies behind it. Difficult behaviour is often the surface of something the child cannot say.

First: look for the cause. Second: record what was seen. Third: pass what was seen to the person who can act.

In a school, the assessment sits inside the graduated approach. A one-to-one tutor is not inside that process, but is often the adult who sees the behaviour first, or alone.

The first step. Disruptive or withdrawn behaviour does not necessarily mean that a child has special educational needs. Where there are concerns, there should be an assessment to find the causal factors. The guidance on mental health and behaviour lists the causes to check: learning difficulties, speech and language, child protection, mental health. Behaviour will often need to be considered with a pupil's needs, but it does not follow that every incident is connected. Whether behaviour connects to a pupil's needs is a question to be checked each time, not an explanation that can be assumed. A child who shouts may be dysregulated rather than defiant.

The second step. Write down the sequence, not just the behaviour, so the record shows what came before it. Keep the note factual and dated, and keep it with safeguarding records rather than in a lesson plan.

The third step. Pass the observation to the named lead, and ask whether the child's support should be reviewed. Where misbehaviour suggests a child may be suffering harm, follow the child protection policy and speak to the safeguarding lead.

The full guide, with sources: blog.jameswallace.tech

In a school, behaviour is managed with a policy: rewards, sanctions, a ladder of consequences. A tutor working with one child has none of that. The three documents that cover behaviour each ask the adult to consider what lies behind it. Difficult behaviour is often the surface of something the child cannot say, and the adult’s job is to look for the cause, record what was seen, and pass it to the person who can act on it. It is not to invent a sanction for an audience of one.

The rule: look for the cause

The SEND code of practice (2015) sets the frame, and it starts by refusing the easy explanation. It says: “Persistent disruptive or withdrawn behaviours do not necessarily mean that a child or young person has SEN. Where there are concerns, there should be an assessment to determine whether there are any causal factors such as undiagnosed learning difficulties, difficulties with communication or mental health issues” (SEND code of practice, paragraph 6.21).

Plainly: a child who is disruptive or withdrawn in a session is not simply difficult, and is not automatically a child with SEND. The point of the rule is the next step. Where there is a concern, the cause is looked for. The same paragraph adds that “early identification and intervention can significantly reduce the use of more costly intervention at a later stage”.

What sits underneath

The DfE guidance Mental health and behaviour in schools (November 2018) lists the causes to check once behaviour is a concern. The setting “should instigate an assessment (as set out in paragraph 3.14) to determine whether there are any underlying factors such as undiagnosed learning difficulties, difficulties with speech and language, child protection concerns, or mental health problems” (paragraph 3.12).

The code of practice makes the same point from the other direction, describing what difficult behaviour can be a sign of. Children and young people “may experience a wide range of social and emotional difficulties which manifest themselves in many ways. These may include becoming withdrawn or isolated, as well as displaying challenging, disruptive or disturbing behaviour. These behaviours may reflect underlying mental health difficulties such as anxiety or depression” (SEND code of practice, paragraph 6.32).

Behaviour that is tied to a need

The DfE Behaviour in schools guidance (February 2024) draws the link to SEND and, importantly, sets a limit on it. It says: “Some behaviours are more likely be associated with particular types of SEND, such as a pupil with speech, language and communication needs who may not understand a verbal instruction. Behaviour will often need to be considered in relation to a pupil’s SEND, although it does not follow that every incident of misbehaviour will be connected to their SEND” (Behaviour in schools, February 2024).

The second half matters most in one-to-one work, where the adult already knows the child’s difficulties. The guidance treats the link as a question to be checked each time, not an explanation that can be assumed. A child with speech and language needs who does not follow an instruction may not have understood it; a child who shouts may be dysregulated rather than defiant. Either way, the answer is a question, not a verdict.

What this looks like with no class

In a school, the assessment the guidance describes sits inside the graduated approach of assess, plan, do, review. A one-to-one tutor is not inside that process, but the tutor is often the adult who sees the behaviour first, or alone. The useful things a tutor does are procedural rather than disciplinary:

  • write down the sequence, not just the behaviour, so the record shows what came before it;
  • keep the note factual and dated, and keep it with safeguarding records rather than in a lesson plan;
  • consider whether the behaviour has changed recently, and whether anything at school, at home or online is known to have changed;
  • pass the observation to the named lead, and ask whether the school or commissioner should review the child’s SEN support.

The code of practice is written for schools and colleges, and it is silent on the self-employed tutor. What travels is the direction of the question: from the behaviour to the need first, not straight from the behaviour to a punishment.

When it is not a behaviour question at all

Two of the documents ask the adult to check something else first. The code of practice says some learning difficulties, “left unaddressed may lead to frustration, which may manifest itself as disaffection, emotional or behavioural difficulties” (paragraph 6.23). So persistent low-level trouble in a session can be the sign of a need that has not been identified or supported, not of a child choosing to misbehave.

Behaviour in schools is direct about the other case. Where misbehaviour gives cause to suspect a pupil is suffering, or is likely to suffer, harm, staff should follow the child protection policy and speak to the designated safeguarding lead. A tutor’s version of that is the lead named by the commissioner, agency or provider, and the observation goes there the same day.

Who does what

A tutor looks for the cause, records the sequence, and passes it on rather than escalating to a sanction. A parent can ask whether behaviour in sessions has prompted a review of their child’s needs. A commissioner can ask how a provider records behaviour observations, where they go, and who acts on them.

Questions to ask

  • When behaviour is a concern, what assessment of the causes is carried out, and by whom? (SEND code of practice, paragraph 6.21)
  • Which causes are on the list to check: learning difficulties, speech and language, child protection, mental health? (Mental health and behaviour in schools, paragraph 3.12)
  • How is behaviour linked to this child’s SEND, and how is that checked rather than assumed? (Behaviour in schools, February 2024)
  • Where does a behaviour observation go, and who reviews the child’s SEN support as a result? (SEND code of practice, paragraphs 6.21 and 6.33)
  • If the behaviour suggests the child may be suffering harm, who is told, and how quickly? (Behaviour in schools, February 2024)

Check this yourself

  • Special educational needs and disability code of practice: 0 to 25 years (2015), paragraphs 6.21, 6.23 and 6.32.
  • Behaviour in schools: advice for headteachers and school staff (DfE, February 2024), the section on behaviour expectations and pupils with SEND.
  • Mental health and behaviour in schools (DfE, November 2018), paragraphs 3.11 to 3.12, on identifying children with possible mental health problems.

Further context

Sources

  1. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/send-code-of-practice-0-to-25
  2. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/behaviour-in-schools--2
  3. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/mental-health-and-behaviour-in-schools--2
About James & his credentials One-to-one tuition

A resource for home

A little structure.
A calmer evening.

The Neurodiverse Learner’s Evening Study Toolkit: seven practical strategies and an evening routine template for families supporting learning at home.

Read the toolkit online

Make yourself comfortable

Reading preferences

Adjust the journal to suit you. Your choices are saved on this device.

Colour
Text size